From Tax Credits to State Guarantees: Vermont’s Education Finance Overhaul

From Tax Credits to State Guarantees: Vermont’s Education Finance Overhaul

With a clear focus on progressivity, transparency, and local control, the Administration’s proposals address nearly every facet of the current education finance framework—from the way property tax credits are calculated to new mechanisms that directly address disparities among school districts.

A Progressive Shift in Tax Relief
The Administration has proposed reconfiguring the education portion of Vermont’s income-based property tax credit. The proposal would replace the current credit with a homestead exemption tiered by income, effective July 1, 2027. This shift is designed to address the “lag” between prior year income figures and current year tax obligations, making it easier for voters and school boards to see how budget votes translate directly into tax bills. Preliminary modeling—based on projected 2024 household income and FY25 property values—suggests that while some households may face modest increases, a range of mitigation strategies exist, such as a revamped circuit breaker credit and a property tax deferral program. These issues were discussed in a joint hearing with the Senate Finance Committee and the House Ways & Means Committee.

Recognizing that some households—especially those with high property values relative to income—might see tax increases under the new homestead exemption system, there was a focused discussion on relief through property tax deferral. Drawing on models from other states, including Maine, Minnesota, and Oregon, the proposal would allow eligible homeowners to defer a portion of their property taxes until the property is sold or ownership changes. While specifics remain under discussion, key ideas include setting deferral limits in tandem with the new homestead exemption and ensuring the program is accessible to those most in need.

Bridging the Gap
The Administration’s sweeping proposal also introduces a “State Guarantee” mechanism aimed at leveling the playing field for school districts. The mechanism calculates a “match rate” by comparing each district’s taxable property wealth per student to the state median. Districts with lower property wealth, which would traditionally struggle to fund education beyond the foundation formula, stand to receive significant state support. Meanwhile, districts with higher local resources would see little to no state guarantee. This targeted approach is intended to ensure more equitable funding while preserving local decision-making.

State Guarantee in Focus
The House Ways and Means Committee reviewed initial bill language that embeds the State Guarantee within a broader statutory reform of Vermont’s education finance system. This version provides precise definitions and detailed formulas—including adjustments to tax rates, billing procedures, and spending limits. Notably, it defines the “State Guarantee Rate” as one minus the ratio of a district’s equalized property tax grand list per pupil to that of the median district, with a floor at zero. This legislative framework also addresses related terms such as “excess spending” (spending above 118% of the statewide average) and specifies comprehensive administrative procedures to ensure accurate tax collection and fund remittance. While the legislative framework’s provisions are intended to create a more robust and enforceable education finance system, they also mean that local administrators, school districts, and taxpayers must navigate a more complex regulatory environment.

Balancing Change and Local Control
Looking ahead, education spending projections and district budgeting recommendations are aimed at improving resource allocation and operational efficiency. By aligning tax relief mechanisms with current income levels and streamlining district operations, the proposal aspires to create a more sustainable funding model while maintaining robust local control—a balance that has been at the center of Vermont’s education finance debates.

As legislators begin a careful review of these proposals, the Vermont Chamber remains committed to engaging in discussions and advocating for the Legislature to address the large-scale systemic issues crucial to reforming Vermont’s education system, ensuring both affordability and sustainability.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

The Vermont Economic Action Plan: Advocating for a Future of Abundance Rather than Scarcity

The Vermont Economic Action Plan: Advocating for a Future of Abundance Rather than Scarcity

This week, Vermont Futures Project Executive Director, Kevin Chu, testified before the House General and Housing Committee and the Senate Economic Development, Housing, and General Affairs Committee, presenting key insights from the Vermont Economic Action Plan. Testimony brought forth conversations about actionable steps to address the root cause of many challenges impacting Vermont businesses, focusing on a future of abundance rather than scarcity.

To advance Vermont’s economic future and improve affordability, Chu emphasized that Vermont must focus on increasing its population to 802,000 by 2035 through recruitment and retention of working-age people. Attracting new people such as remote workers, military retirees, and international professionals, will strengthen the workforce, support business success, and broaden the tax base. Additionally, Vermont should aim to increase the labor force participation rate to 70% by 2035 by aligning education with employer needs and reducing barriers to employment.

The ability to grow businesses in Vermont ties directly to housing availability and infrastructure. The plan sets a target of 350,000 non-seasonal homes by 2035 and calls for reduced development timelines alongside 40% reductions in regulatory costs. Legislators engaged with the presentation content and discussed the intersections of growth and migration with infrastructure and transportation improvements.

The Vermont Futures Project’s testimony reinforced the urgent need to solve problems, quantified the scale of action needed, and outlined incremental steps to improve affordability. The testimony demonstrates the critical need for policy to be informed by data. The Vermont Chamber will continue working with lawmakers to advance policies that support business growth, streamline regulations, and improve economic opportunities across the state.

Access the full Economic Action Report here.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Education Finance Overhaul Takes Center Stage at the State House

Education Finance Overhaul Takes Center Stage at the State House

This week, legislators began a detailed review of Governor Scott’s proposed “Foundation Formula” for education finance, though actual bill language has yet to be seen. The foundation formula, which sets a base per-pupil amount of $13,200, adds weighted allocations for special education, English Language Learners, and career and technical education. While the plan aims to centralize services and encourage district efficiencies, legislators requested further clarification—particularly around local control and how these changes would roll out over time.

The Joint Fiscal Office also presented findings on moving from a property-tax-based education funding model to an income-tax-based system. The Vermont Chamber maintains that an income-based education tax would not address the root causes of rising education costs. Instead, it would impose greater volatility, administrative complexities, and potentially higher marginal rates on families and businesses already managing significant tax burdens.

As Vermont remains third in the nation for tax collections per capita, refining the existing property tax structure, paired with targeted relief mechanisms such as the property tax credit, is a more prudent and balanced approach to ensuring equitable funding while preserving housing affordability and economic vitality. The Chamber will continue to advocate for the Legislature to address the large-scale systemic issues crucial to reforming Vermont’s education system, ensuring both affordability and sustainability.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Senator Welch Hears From Vermont Chamber and Members on Potential Tariffs

Senator Welch Hears From Vermont Chamber and Members on Potential Tariffs

The Vermont Chamber of Commerce, committed to advancing Vermont’s economy and representing businesses statewide, participated in a critical roundtable led by Senator Peter Welch to address the potential economic impact of proposed new tariffs. Vermont businesses, including manufacturers, farmers, and service providers, depend heavily on a strong trade relationship with Canada—Vermont’s largest trading partner. The Chamber views the maintenance of open markets and consistent trade policies as essential for economic stability and growth.

Potential tariffs, which could raise costs by 25% on raw materials, construction components, grain, and manufacturing inputs, pose significant risks to Vermont’s small businesses. The Vermont Chamber emphasized how such tariffs could lead to higher costs for essential goods and services, affecting businesses across sectors like agriculture, construction, and manufacturing. Without the capacity to absorb increased expenses, many businesses would be forced to pass these costs on to consumers, exacerbating the state’s affordability challenges and affecting the financial well-being of Vermont families.

As the Vermont Chamber continues its advocacy efforts, it remains focused on promoting policies that maintain economic growth while protecting Vermont businesses from financial instability. Working closely with state and federal leaders, the Vermont Chamber will strive to ensure that Vermont’s economic ecosystem remains resilient, with an emphasis on preventing harmful impacts from sudden cost increases and supporting long-term investment in workforce and community development.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Governor Scott’s Budget: Fixing Systems, Not Just Funding Them

Governor Scott’s Budget: Fixing Systems, Not Just Funding Them

Governor Phil Scott delivered his budget address on Tuesday, presenting a $9 billion spending plan focused on education reform, housing expansion, and public safety—without increasing taxes or fees. Emphasizing the need for long-term structural fixes rather than temporary funding patches, the Governor underscored the importance of making Vermont more affordable and competitive for businesses and working families. His priorities align closely with the Vermont Chamber’s legislative agenda, which advocates for affordability, workforce development, and strategic economic growth.

Fixing Education

With Vermont spending $2.4 billion annually on education while student outcomes remain inconsistent, the Governor proposed a major overhaul. His plan includes consolidating school administration into five regional districts to improve efficiency, standardizing student funding and teacher salaries, and expanding career training programs to better prepare students for the workforce. To prevent a projected 6% property tax increase, he proposed using $77 million from the General Fund—aligning with the Chamber’s focus on fiscal responsibility and affordability.

Building Housing That Supports Workforce Growth

Vermont needs at least 7,000 additional housing units to meet demand, support employers, and sustain economic growth. The budget fully funds the Vermont Housing and Conservation Board with $37 million and provides $4 million for the Vermont Housing Improvement Program to help small-scale landlords bring units to market faster. Additionally, a one-time $40 million investment in water, sewer, and stormwater infrastructure will unlock stalled housing projects. These measures support the Chamber’s call for workforce housing solutions that directly address Vermont’s labor shortage.

Strengthening Public Safety for Businesses

Rising crime rates, including a 40% increase in aggravated assaults and a doubling of retail theft since 2018, have significantly impacted downtown businesses. The budget proposes tougher sentencing for repeat offenders, increased funding for pre-trial supervision, and expanded addiction recovery services. These steps align with the Chamber’s advocacy for policies that create safe, vibrant economic hubs for businesses and communities.

Investing in Infrastructure & Economic Resilience

The budget allocates $858 million for roads, bridges, and public transit, expands Downtown and Village Center Tax Credits by $2 million, and creates a new disaster recovery fund to provide immediate relief for businesses impacted by natural disasters. With a $15 million investment in Efficiency Vermont, the state aims to support climate resilience without raising costs for ratepayers—an approach that dovetails with the Chamber’s focus on sustainable economic growth.

A Shared Vision for Vermont’s Economic Future

Governor Scott’s message was clear: Vermont must fix broken systems, not just fund them. His budget priorities reflect many of the Vermont Chamber’s legislative goals—fiscal responsibility, workforce development, housing expansion, and public safety improvements. As the legislative session unfolds, the Chamber will continue working to ensure that policies promote long-term economic stability, business competitiveness, and a high quality of life for all Vermonters.

A complete transcript of the Governor’s budget address can be found here.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Revenue Forecast: Vermont’s Resilient Economy and Emerging Challenges

Revenue Forecast: Vermont’s Resilient Economy and Emerging Challenges

The Emergency Board met this week to review the Consensus Economic Forecast, which showcased Vermont’s strong but shifting economic landscape. Productivity remains high, supported by record-breaking stock market performance and 48 consecutive months of job growth. Workforce mobility continues to shape the labor market, with approximately 10,000 workers moving into and out of the state annually. While this activity brings opportunities, it also presents challenges for labor market stability.

State revenues are slightly above expectations, with Fiscal Year 2025 estimates showing overall collections 3.7% higher than projected. However, performance varies across major funding streams:

  • General Fund: Revenues exceeded expectations by 6.0%, driven by strong personal income and corporate tax collections.
  • Education Fund: A 2.1% shortfall stems from weaker sales and use taxes, meals and rooms taxes, and declining lottery revenues.
  • Transportation Fund: Revenues were 2.7% above estimates, bolstered by strong vehicle purchase activity.

Certain tax streams produced mixed results. The Childcare Payroll Tax fell behind expectations, while the Property Transfer Tax exceeded projections. Revenue from cigarette and e-cigarette sales declined but was partially offset by growth in nicotine pouches.

Adjustments to Vermont’s tax system also revealed uneven outcomes:

  • Sales & Use Tax: Expanding the tax to include sectors like cloud-based services underperformed expectations.
  • Short-Term Rental Surcharge: Marginally below projections.
  • Motor Vehicle Purchase & Use Tax: Surpassed targets due to pent-up demand and tariff concerns.

National trends add further complexity. A reliance on federal stimulus funds has temporarily supported Vermont’s economy, but as those funds taper off, pressure mounts for sustainable fiscal solutions. Additionally, uncertainty surrounding potential inflation, interest rates, and tax reforms under the incoming federal administration could impact the state’s economic trajectory.

The ongoing legislative session provides a critical opportunity to adjust fiscal priorities and prepare for these challenges. Vermont businesses should stay engaged in policy discussions to ensure their voices are heard. The next revenue update, scheduled for July, will offer further insight into the state’s fiscal outlook.

This forecast highlights both opportunities and uncertainties for Vermont’s business community, reinforcing the importance of adaptability and collaboration in navigating the state’s economic future.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Vermont Chamber Advocates for Economic Growth and Housing Solutions 

Vermont Chamber Advocates for Economic Growth and Housing Solutions

The Vermont Chamber advocacy team engaged with both House and Senate committees to outline priorities aimed at fortifying Vermont’s economy. Discussions centered on housing affordability, workforce challenges, regulatory reforms, technology, and positioning Vermont as a premier relocation destination. 

Tourism and manufacturing were highlighted as economic pillars, each contributing $3 billion annually and employing thousands of Vermonters. The Chamber’s Foundation, the Vermont Futures Project, was spotlighted for its focus on long-term economic planning, ensuring these critical sectors continue to drive statewide prosperity. 

Housing availability and affordability took center stage as a pressing concern. The Chamber will continue advocating for meaningful reforms to reduce construction costs, improve infrastructure, and expand access, emphasizing the importance of addressing Vermont’s demographic challenges and workforce gaps to sustain economic vitality. 

The Chamber emphasized the integral connection between business growth and wage growth, presenting data that reinforces the need for collaborative efforts to support businesses. Economic development remains a priority for the Vermont Chamber, and the team is poised to work alongside lawmakers to ensure businesses have the resources and environment necessary to thrive. 

To bolster advocacy efforts surrounding technology issues, the Vermont Chamber introduced attorney Josh Diamond from Dinse, who the Chamber has hired on retainer. With his extensive legal expertise and six years of experience as Vermont’s Deputy Attorney General, Josh will provide critical insights and representation for Vermont’s business community on emerging technology challenges. 

The team will do additional introductions next week and will dive into expert testimony on legislation. Through proactive collaboration with lawmakers, stakeholders, and industry leaders, the Vermont Chamber continues to champion policies that advance Vermont’s economy and enhance quality of life for all. 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Laying the Groundwork for Education Finance Reform 

Laying the Groundwork for Education Finance Reform

Legislative committees discussed Vermont’s education finance system this week, emphasizing the complex ties between funding, governance, and education quality, and the need for reforms both to address these challenges and tackle high costs head on.  While awaiting the Governor’s proposed education finance reforms in the January 28 budget address, House and Senate committees reviewed the current funding system, its formula, and potential improvements. 

Elements of the Governor’s proposal were previewed by members of his administration and included simplifying tax structures, recalibrating the Common Level of Appraisal, and ensuring taxpayer capacity aligns with funding obligations. Testimonies from the Department of Taxes and the Agency of Education also emphasized the need for a more streamlined and transparent system. Proposals for statewide teacher contracts and construction aid policies further underscored the need for cohesive, statewide strategies that will reduce costs and increase affordability. 

One proposed funding formula, informed by models from states like Massachusetts and Maine, aims to establish a base funding amount per student, with adjustments for factors like school size, cost of living, and student needs. Legislators discussed implementing the formula in Vermont, focusing on the base amount, property taxes, and teacher compensation. 

Continued, focused dialogue among the legislature, educational leaders, and other stakeholders will be a priority this session. Addressing the large-scale systemic issues is crucial to reforming Vermont’s education system to ensure both affordability and sustainability. 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Governor Phil Scott’s Inaugural Speech Echoes Vermont Chamber’s Priorities

Governor Phil Scott's Inaugural Speech Echoes Vermont Chamber’s Priorities
Governor Phil Scott pictured at a podium speaking at the 2025 inauguration

Governor Phil Scott’s inaugural address delivered a clear call to action on the most pressing challenges, including affordability, housing, education reform, and workforce sustainability. These priorities reflect significant overlap with the Vermont Chamber of Commerce’s ongoing advocacy efforts, emphasizing shared goals to strengthen Vermont’s economy and improve the quality of life for its residents. Keeping affordability and Vermont’s challenging demographics at the forefront, the address focused on:

  • Affordability and economic growth
  • Addressing the housing crisis
  • Student-centered education reforms
  • Moving forward together

Affordability and Economic Growth
A central theme of Governor Scott’s speech was Vermont’s need to tackle its affordability crisis. He noted the state’s reputation as a high-tax destination and emphasized that Vermont cannot afford to lose more residents due to rising costs. A vision of achieving affordability through economic growth rather than tax increases aligns with the Vermont Chamber’s emphasis on fostering business resilience and attracting new residents. Both aim to reduce the financial burdens facing Vermont’s families and businesses while expanding economic opportunities.

The Governor’s message of bolstering opportunities for working Vermonters and supporting local communities parallels the Chamber’s push for innovative workforce development solutions. Efforts to promote Vermont as a destination for skilled workers and investing in community development directly impact the other challenges facing Vermont. The economic impact of a shrinking workforce remains a key focus for the Vermont Futures Project, which continues to highlight the issue and provide valuable data to support solutions.

Housing: A Shared Priority
The Vermont Chamber has long advocated for increased housing supply by addressing root causes and barriers to development. Governor Scott echoed this urgent need, calling for the construction of 8,000 new homes annually—a figure Vermont is far from achieving. The speech advocated for treating housing development as an emergency by streamlining regulatory barriers, investing in infrastructure, and revitalizing workforce. Affordable housing for all incomes is critical to retaining employees, attracting new talent, and fostering economic growth.

Education: Tackling Costs and Improving Outcomes for Students
The Governor delivered a pointed critique of Vermont’s current education funding model, highlighting dramatic cost increases that outpace the value delivered. With the current expected 5.9% increase this year, property taxes will have increased by 33% over three years, a trend further compounded by increases in education-related revenue sources, many of which depend on taxes collected and remitted by the business community. These include 100% of sales tax revenue, one-third of purchase and use tax revenue, one-quarter of rooms and meals tax revenue, 100% of the new short-term rental surcharge, as well as lottery funds and general fund transfers. Despite these escalating costs, Vermont serves only 80,300 students across an “out of scale” education system with high administrative overhead and small class sizes.

Scott pledged to introduce a multi-year plan to overhaul the system focusing on a student-centered funding formula and a more efficient governance structure. This proposal includes streamlining administrative costs, rethinking local school board responsibilities, and implementing guardrails to ensure fiscal discipline. By addressing these systemic inefficiencies, the Governor aims to contain costs while improving outcomes—both of which are essential to Vermont’s economic future.
This approach complements the Vermont Chamber’s advocacy for critical cost-saving reforms that prioritize addressing root issues over simply increasing funding.

Moving Forward Together
Governor Scott’s speech reflected a shared vision with the Vermont Chamber: focusing on practical, long-term solutions to Vermont’s most significant challenges. From housing to affordability to workforce development, his priorities align with the Chamber’s commitment to advancing Vermont’s economy.

As the legislative session progresses, the Vermont Chamber will collaborate with lawmakers, the administration, and other stakeholders to achieve shared goals. The Governor, Speaker, and Pro Tem have all emphasized the importance of setting priorities, maintaining focus, and taking a collaborative approach. The Vermont Chamber will look for this commitment every day throughout the session, and expect all leadership to continue driving progress, delivering outcomes, and advocating for policies that support Vermont’s businesses and communities.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT NEWS

Op-Ed: The Vermont Chamber’s 2025 Legislative Priorities

Common Ground: Working Together to Address Vermont’s Affordability Crisis

Each year, the Vermont Chamber of Commerce outlines our legislative priorities with one focus in mind: creating the conditions to advance the Vermont economy. This year, our goals align closely with those voiced by Vermonters at the polls: addressing affordability, fostering economic growth, and doing the hard work to solve Vermont’s toughest challenges. 

Affordability is at the forefront of these challenges. Vermonters are grappling with rising costs, driven by demographic pressures and systemic issues in areas such as education finance spending, housing, and healthcare. Based on data compiled by the Vermont Futures Project, our state must add an average of 13,500 people to its workforce annually through 2035 to keep the economy thriving in the face of demographic shifts. Meanwhile, meeting current housing demand will require tripling Vermont’s housing output to produce 36,000 new units by 2029.

Addressing this level of need is even more pressing given Vermont’s ranking as the third-highest state in the nation for tax collections per capita, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Property and individual income taxes remain Vermont’s largest sources of revenue—placing additional stress on families and businesses already struggling with limited housing options and rising costs. While band-aid solutions might feel appealing, real progress requires honest conversations, a shared commitment, and a willingness to embrace compromise. We need solutions that tackle the root causes, not just the symptoms. 

Last year’s success in modernizing Act 250 demonstrated how stakeholders with historically opposing sides commit to working together, and in doing so, real progress can be made—even when the process is challenging and compromises are required. By remaining fully engaged and working through disagreements, participants honored diverse perspectives and paved the way for continued collaboration, providing a blueprint for how to accomplish meaningful change. This model of purposeful engagement—where people listen to different viewpoints, set aside rhetoric, and remain focused on shared goals—must be a cornerstone of how we move forward in Montpelier and beyond. As we look ahead, whether in the State House, the boardroom, or around the kitchen table, we must prioritize this spirit of cooperation to address our affordability crisis and build a stronger future for businesses and communities across the state. 

The Vermont Chamber is committed to playing an active role in this process. We will advocate for thoughtful, data-driven policies that reduce costs, grow our economy, and create opportunities for all Vermonters. Vermont’s challenges, from housing shortages to healthcare costs, do not rest on the shoulders of any one party, organization, or community. Making meaningful reforms will require all stakeholders—legislators, administration officials, advocates, businesses, and individuals—to engage in difficult conversations and embrace compromise. Only through a shared sense of responsibility—and shared accountability for the outcomes—can we create the conditions for inclusive and forward-thinking problem-solving. Blame and partisanship must give way to open-minded discussion and creative ideas that improve Vermonters’ lives. 

As we begin the new legislative session, the Vermont Chamber calls on our leaders to remain engaged in discussions, continue the dialogue, and keep conversations focused on results. It’s time to move beyond rhetoric and engage in the real work of making Vermont more affordable and sustainable for all. By doing so, we can ensure our state’s economy remains vibrant, our communities remain livable, and our future remains bright.